Best Pepper Mill America’s Test Kitchen

Pepper is a commonly used ingredient in the kitchen. Freshly ground pepper adds a natural taste and aroma to your food. Pre-ground stuff in jars and cans may lose the deliciousness of its nature.

Pepper releases savory oils when they are crashed. To enjoy the freshest taste and fragment we recommend pepper mills.

Pepper mills or pepper grinders crush the spices. They allow the users to select the size of their choice from fine to coarse. The best pepper grinder adds taste to your meals and gives a new look to your dining.

We are here with the top products of the market to make your choice easier and comfortable. This list contains a detailed review of each product:

5 Best Pepper Mill America’s Test Kitchen

  • Fletcher’s Mill Salt & Pepper Border Grill
  • Cole $ Mason Derwent Pepper Grinder
  • Peugeot Paris u’Select Pepper Mill
  • Gravity Electric Pepper Grinder
  • OXO Good Grips Pepper Grinder

1. Fletcher’s Mill Salt & Pepper Border Grill

Classy Fletcher is handcrafted in America under the supervision of a family-owned business. This mill is made of wood and sleek in design with very few flaws with its performance.

Fletcher mill is oversized than Peagueot Paris Mill it has a much larger space and requires removing top metal pieces when you need to refill it. Fletcher mill is designed with a large opening that makes it easier to pour peppercorns. It has several coarseness options that fit with your dining settings.

Border Grill pepper mill is designed for chefs who want complete control over the seasoning of their dishes. This mill has the unique feature of a Lock Grind grinding system that gives consistency in results whether you want fine grinds for fish, medium for gravy, and coarse for meats.

Grinding in the mill is done in two steps; firstly volatile oils and flavors are obtained by crushing the peppercorns; next, they are ground to the chosen consistency for a perfect result. This mill is easy to clean and gives a long-lasting guarantee.


  • Made of recyclable material
  • Traditional look


  • Attention Difficult adjustments

View At Amazon

2. Cole $ Mason Derwent Pepper Grinder

This best fusion mill is a cone burr grinder made of carbon steel. It gives a smooth and easy grind and is an attractive addition to your kitchen or table.

This mill can fill with a half cup of peppercorns per chunk and can grind from ultra-fine to crushed. It is easy to fill and the use of glass in design makes it more beautiful in looks. Clear sides of glass let you know when to refill but this side also has a drawback of exposing heat and light through it clear body which expert said can degrade flavor.

Adjust easily to produce all grinds depending on what you are cooking by simply twisting the bottom section of the mill. This mill creates the precise and accurate size of the grind and is efficient in use but difficult to twist or turn with oily and wet hands at the same time.


  • Easy to use and adjust
  • Holds more quantity of peppercorns


  • Hard to grip with oily or wet hands
  • Direct expose of heat and light degrade flavor

View At Amazon

3. Peugeot Paris u’Select Pepper Mill

Peugeot mill is the best mill since its arrival in the market. It was the first-ever mill introduced in 1874 by France and trusted by several restaurants and professionals. This beautiful and classy mill is easy to use it has wooden grooves that give you an easy grip on the product.

Adjustment of this mill is quite easy (unlike much of the competitors). It has six grinding settings that are labeled on the base so you can easily select the size of your choice by turning the mill, it will never break the consistency of size in the middle.

It has sharp razer teeth which finely crashed the peppercorns into the powdery form and add marvelous taste and aroma to your food. This feature ensures that the setting won’t change until you want. The opening of the mill is wide so you will not face any difficulty shattering peppercorns around the table during the refill process.

For the best results, it is suggested that you should use dry and hard peppercorns. Another feature that increases its worth is that Peugeot is committed to protecting nature its all-production materials are easily recycled.


  • Easy to adjust and use
  • Environment-friendly production
  • Attractive look


  • Relatively expensive
  • Bad customer service

View At Amazon

4. Gravity Electric Pepper Grinder

Gravity pepper is a mill designed with the combination of purest and highest quality stainless steel and acrylic material which offers long-time durability. It grinds the toughest peppercorns and spices with just single pushing of a button.

This mill doesn’t need both hands to operate it will give convenience in your kitchen time. It has an extra blue light function over other products that make it beautiful and make the number of spices clear to you. you just need to flip the grinder and you will have freshly ground spices.

You need to turn the black knob on the top and can choose the coarseness of your spices. The modern and fashionable look of the grinder makes it a perfect choice for a gift or a beautiful addition to a kitchen.

For enjoying the benefits of this product, it is recommended that remove the batteries if you are not using the product for an extended period. You can easily clean the product with a soft piece of cloth or even with a brush.

A transparent glass body makes it easy to refill even necessary. This mill has a whole year warranty and also offers a full refund within thirty days if you are not happy with the product.


  • Easy to wash and refill
  • Convenient and fast grinding speed
  • Easy to install batteries


  • Beware sometimes it starts automatically
  • Some users find blue light irritating

View At Amazon

5. OXO Good Grips Pepper Grinder

Ultimately OXO functions are similar to other manual mills but upward design elements make it different from others. It stands on the table grind and serve from the top.

You can easily refill it by removing the cap and can adjust the grinder size from the side of the grinder so you easily adjust the grinder for fine pepper to your salad and can quickly get the coarse peppers for your steaks. It limited the mess on the table or floor when you put down the grinder.

A clear acrylic body makes it easy for you to know how much pepper is left in the mill. You can simply empty it in a while and can fill salt and other spices you want to grind fresh.


  • Less expensive than competitors
  • Limit the mess


  • Difficult to grind larger peppercorns
  • Pepper may stick in the bottom

View At Amazon

Buying Guide For Best Pepper Mill

Pepper mills are present in a number of varieties. They are present in different shapes, sizes, and colors. It becomes difficult for you to choose the right one. We have solved your problem in this buying guide.


Grinders are present in different types of material. They are made from wood, glass, and hand-crafting. Pepper mills made from wood are durable and can be more difficult to clean.

Metal is durable but if the chef has a wrist problem, it becomes difficult for him to handle it. The best among these are pepper mills made from plastic and acrylic material. They are easy to clean and are lightweight.


The size of pepper mills varies from a 4-inch to a large 24-inch mill. The size of the pepper mill never affects the quality but it impacts the appearance.

If pepper is the last touch to your meal, prefer the mill with a tall height. On the other hand, short-height pepper mills can be easily knocked.

Filling Method

It’s an important factor that we should consider before purchasing a pepper mill. Your mill should be easy to fill, easily removed, and quick to unscrew at the bottom. It is also important that the chamber must be clean because it holds the peppercorns. Thus, it becomes clear to see everything easily.


Q1: Can I use my pepper mill for grinding the salt?

A: Yes, you can definitely use the pepper mill for grinding the salt. The materials used for salt composition and pepper grinding determine whether we can use it for salt or not.

Q2: Does every peppermill has an adjustable coarseness setting?

A: No, every model has not this setting. Lower-end machines don’t have this setting while the higher-end mills have this setting. That’s why they work more efficiently.

Wrapping it up

We have created this amazing guide for you to get an excellent investment and purchase the best peppermill while sticking to your budget.

For this, we have added our best efforts to share the first person tested experiences, guidelines on how you can grab the best peppermill according to your needs and requirements.

Not just that, we have even shared some options to make your buying process easier, as well as how you can safely use the peppermill set to do your job. In a nutshell, we have summarized and tried to help you get your imagined best peppermill!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to Top