Best Cookie Sheets America’s Test Kitchen

You get the glory from a Dutch oven or slick frying pan but when it comes to the versatility of the kitchen, cookie sheets or baking sheets are perfect. When your pans get stained or worn out you realize that they are not enough.

You must have a perfect cookie sheet to bake cookies ideally. They cradle cookies and scones during baking, they are perfect for roasting root veggies and, as sheet pan dinner fans, you can prepare a perfect meal.

Cookie sheets are incredibly versatile pieces of the kitchen for a good reason. There are technical differences between baking sheets, cookie sheets, and sheet pans.

We will use all of them freely in one post. Cookies slide off the other sides easily in cookie sheets. They are perfect for making cookies in perfect and desirous shapes.

Cookie sheets come in a huge variety. It becomes surprisingly hard to find the best one with perfect features. The best cookie sheets are durable, have even heat distribution.

They streamline your recipes when you are whipping up a batch of cookies or roasting veggies. We have written a detailed article to help you purchase the best cookie sheet.

6 Best Cookie Sheets Reviews

  • OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Cookie Sheet
  • Nordic Ware Commercial Baker’s Half Sheet
  • Circulon Nonstick Cookie Sheet
  • Wildone Baking Sheet
  • Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware Baking Sheet
  • Rachael Ray Nonstick Cookie Pan Set

1. OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Cookie Sheet


OXO cookie sheets are typically praised for their durability and nonstick surfaces. These cookie sheets are made of high-grade aluminum steel that provides fast and even heat distribution.

The Swiss-engineered, ceramic-reinforced, two-layer coating allows for easy food release while protecting against scratching, staining, and corrosion.

The micro-textured pattern minimizes the Pan’s contact with food for more airflow and even baking. The generous edge provides a secure grip. Hand washes only.

The textured surface minimizes the surface contact and promotes airflow. It adds structural rigidity to help prevent warping and staining. It provides visible pan dimension markings on the top surface to help easy and quick identification.

Square-rolled edges add reinforcement for structure, strength, and durability, and provide a secure grip for easy handling and transferring to and from the oven. Generous slip provides a secure grip that ends in getting perfect cookies.

Pros

  • Aluminized Steel Construction
  • Ergonomic edge
  • Textured surface
  • Square-rolled edges

Cons

  • Needs adjusted temperature for baking

View At Amazon


2. Nordic Ware Commercial Baker’s Half Sheet


This natural commercial bakeware is made of pure aluminum which will never rust for a lifetime of durability. For sweet or savory baking; from cookies to sheet pan dinners, this is the pan you’ll reach for.

Aluminum super heat conductivity bakes food perfectly and provides even heat distribution. Reinforced encapsulated steel rim prevents warping and adds strength to the cookie.

Wires are bent perfectly to fit inside the rim of bakeware sheets. It provides durability, even heat distribution, and structural support. Pans are made of a special hardened aluminum alloy that provides superbly uniform heat conductivity and maximizes scratch resistance.

Shiny and non-porous natural aluminum provide natural nonstick performance. Embossed Nordic Ware logo signal quality and value from a trusted legacy brand for over 70 years.

Pros

  • Dishwasher safe
  • Natural Aluminum Pans
  • Steel rim fully encapsulated
  • Even heat distribution

Cons

  • Slightly Expensive

View At Amazon


3. Circulon Nonstick Cookie Sheet


If you want a nonstick cookie sheet, we must recommend you for paying for this cookie sheet. It is one of the amazing Nonstick cookie sheets.

Heavy-duty steel construction offers uniform heat distribution, and the cookie sheets’ warp-resistant rolled edges provide extra strength.

TOTAL Food Release System features metal-utensil-safe premium nonstick on raised circles for superior baking release and effortless cleanup.

The rolled-rim design includes distinctive chocolate brown color inside and out, and wide handles for plenty of grips, even with bulky oven mitts.

Blend all this together, and that’s the recipe for lifelong baking enjoyment. And once the baking is done, the exceptional nonstick technology keeps the cleanup easy.

Oven safe to 450°F, this bakeware brings the Circulon time-and-energy-saving approach to home baking. The cookie sheets truly deliver both the good and the goods, for a well-rounded life.
The Circulon Nonstick Bakeware Cookie Pan Bakeware Set delivers nonstick baking results and it is the best overall.

Pros

  • Superior technology
  • Easy to clean
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Long-lasting performance

Cons

  • Speeds up bake time, can’t clean it with a steel wool

View At Amazon


4. Wildone Baking Sheet


Cookie sheets can feel flimsy because they don’t have the structure of wire-reinforced rims. This Cookie sheet feels sturdy because of heavy-duty construction. No more aluminum in your food, great replacement to aluminum pan.

The baking sheet pan and cooling rack are made of high-quality 18/0 stainless steel without chemical coating or any other materials. Rust-resistant and durable for many years.

This cookie sheet is made with heavy-duty steel and a scratch-resistant surface. If you prefer a baking sheet for making cookies, then this one is the best choice. Cleaning is a breeze, deep full sides all around prevent food juice from flowing everywhere to keep your oven neat.

It is ideal for baking cinnamon rolls, sticky buns, brownies, cornbread, and fruit cobblers and etc. Food heats evenly and comes out perfectly.

Pros

  • Smooth roll edges
  • Healthy and durable
  • Superior mirror finish

Cons

  • Made of fairly thin stainless steel

View At Amazon


5. Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware Baking Sheet


Although it is bakeware, it fits perfectly in an oven. The baking sheet has raised edges let you use it to bake everything from cookies to sheet cakes with no-spill; the Brownie pan is the perfect size for delicious and perfectly cooked brownies.

The Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware makes it easy to bake all your favorite cakes and cookies with confidence. Constructed with heavy-gauge steel cores, designed to brown even the most delicate cookies evenly, making them hardworking kitchen tools for years to come.

The interlocking nonstick layers deliver a high-performance release, minimizing broken cookies and stuck-on baked goods. Your bakeware is oven safe up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit. From moist cookies to perfect pizza crust, achieve professional results in your own kitchen.

While bakeware is dishwasher safe, hand washing using a liquid dishwashing detergent and a non-abrasive cleaning sponge will keep your bakeware looking better longer.

Pros

  • Heavy-gauge steel core heats evenly
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Oven-safe to 500 degrees Fahrenheit

Cons

  • Too big for a small oven
  • Not ideal for high temperatures

View At Amazon


6. Rachael Ray Nonstick Cookie Pan Set


If you want to purchase stunning cookie sheets, this Cookie Pan set will never disappoint you. These stunning cookie pans are the perfect choice for rustling up a quick batch of cookies for your hungry kids.

You can also bake up other types of sweets or savory treats. This Cookie Pan set is made from premium quality durable carbon steel that resists warping.

Long-lasting nonstick provides excellent food release and easy cleanup. Bold-colored, extra-wide grippy handles on the 3-piece sheet set provide a confident grasp.

An oven is safe to 500 degrees Fahrenheit. With a small, medium, and large cookie sheet, enjoy the convenience of three sizes to do everything.

The nonstick baking sheet set features bold-colored, extra-wide grippy handles that provide a confident grasp when pulling items from the oven and are oven safe to 500°F.

Hit a triple play with the Rachael Ray 47425 Bakeware 3-Piece Nonstick Cookie Pan Set that includes three durable baking pans for creating delish baked foods.

Pros

  • Solid and durable Carbon steel
  • Easy to hold and carry
  • Attractive Dart gray surface

Cons

  • Not Dishwasher safe
  • Metal can bend in high temperatures

View At Amazon


Buying Guide For Best Cookie Sheets

There are some important factors to be aware of before you make your final purchase.

Size

Most standard ovens have a baking rack that’s around 22 inches wide, so I recommend a sheet that’s the standard 13-by-18-inch size (a baker’s half) as it’s not too big, giving the heated room to circulate.

And it’s not too small either, allowing you to bake a large number of treats at once. Another perk of going with a standard size is that precut parchment paper is a perfect fit, with no trimming required.

If you have a commercial extra-large oven, you could get away with using a full-size sheet pan, which measures 26 by 18 inches. But that’s going to be too big for most ovens. Smaller-sized sheets also work, it will just take longer to get through your dough if you are baking in batches.

Non-Stick

Nonstick usually means it’s a thinner sheet of steel that has been coated with a thin layer of polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE)/Teflon – which often means it’s more prone to heat warping, scuffs, and uneven cooking.

If you’re hesitant about potential exposure to toxins and chemicals, you’ll want to avoid the nonstick options, as they’re usually coated with chemicals that may off-gas when heated to high temperatures.

The good thing about using this style is you don’t have to worry about oiling your pan or using parchment paper, and food comes off very easily without it.

Rimmed Vs Non-rimmed

Which of these options is better? This is a difficult question to answer, as there are pros and cons to both. That being said, what is commonly referred to as “baking sheets” are usually the ones with rimmed edges, and cookie sheets are those without edges.

A rim can actually block the circulation of hot air in your oven, preventing cookies from baking evenly. Without the edge, you usually have more available baking space as well.

The size of the rim can vary dramatically, from thin to thick and short to tall. When using this style, I have found that as long as I have enough workspace in the pan, I don’t mind the rim.


FAQs?

Q1: How a cookie sheet gets warped?

A: In the case of your metal baking sheets and pans, multiple surfaces need to expand — the bottom of the pan or sheet and the four raised edges along its perimeter. As they heat up, they don’t all expand at the same rate. The bottom will expand slightly more than the raised lip. This creates stress at the folded edges.

Q2: Can I use a sheet pan for baking my cookies?

A: While baking sheets can be used to bake things like cookies, which have a somewhat thick and solid dough, they can be used for plenty of other foods as well, which might not share the same properties. A common use of a baking pan is for roasting vegetables.


Conclusion

Cookie sheets have become an important tool in the kitchen. As we consider it a perfect tool for baking cookies and cakes. Cookie sheets come in a great variety; it becomes difficult for you to choose the perfect one.

We have written a detailed article to help you know about the best Cookie sheets. Read this detailed article and then make your final purchase.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to Top